For anyone comparing a 3d ai maker for tabletop resin work, this test follows Meshy 3D Agent from concept generation to a prepared STL and records the approvals, waits, sizing choices, and other friction along the way.
My first message to Meshy 3D Agent asked for four concepts of a 32 mm dwarf warrior. Meshy showed four "Creating image" lines for about 6 minutes, and after a reload its reply was gone, with 0 credits charged and nothing saying it had failed. I re-sent the same sentence. From there the run cost me 3 Approve clicks, a choice card with a select and a Submit, and 4 clicks in a download dialog that opened at 12.0 cm. Snapshapy's 3D Agent took the same three messages with 0 approvals and finished with 2 clicks: Export, then STL.
I tested Meshy 3D Agent at meshy.ai and Snapshapy's 3D Agent at snapshapy.com, one conversation each, on my own paid accounts (Meshy Pro and Snapshapy Pro). I ran the Snapshapy side the next day, after an update; the Meshy numbers are from the first day.
The three messages, typed verbatim on both sides: "Design 4 concepts for a 32 mm tabletop miniature: a dwarf warrior with an axe and a round shield.", then "Use option 1 and make it a 3D model.", then "Prepare it for resin printing at 32 mm tall." On every choice card I picked the first option. This article logs each step as friction: what I had to click, wait for, or redo before the next message.
My verdict in 60 seconds — Meshy 3D Agent 63/100, Snapshapy 87/100
Meshy 3D Agent ends with a clean, dense 32 mm STL, but the path there ran through a silent 6-minute hang, three approval cards, a choice card and a dialog that defaulted to the wrong size.
- Clicks beyond the 3 messages — Meshy 3/10 · Snapshapy 9/10 — about 11 (re-send, reload, 3 Approve, select + Submit, 4 dialog clicks) vs 2, 5.5×
- Message 1 reliability — Meshy 3/10 · Snapshapy 9/10 — a ≈385 s first try with no images and a vanished reply vs a reply in about 9 s
- Whole-run job time — Meshy 4/10 · Snapshapy 8/10 — ≈1,189 s including the failed first try vs ≈430 s, 2.8×
- Size at 32 mm — Meshy 4/10 · Snapshapy 9/10 — dialog default 12.0 cm with Resize off vs "exactly 32 mm tall with no slicer scaling"
- Print step — Meshy 4/10 · Snapshapy 9/10 — choice card + approval, 10 credits, ≈363 s vs free, 6.6 s
- Print-ready file — Meshy 8/10 · Snapshapy 9/10 — both watertight, 1 body, 0 non-manifold edges, 32.00 mm tall
- Print detail / mesh density — Meshy 9/10 · Snapshapy 6/10 — 7,754,470 vs 59,928 faces, 0.035 vs 0.309 mm mean edge
- Credits for the run — Meshy 4/10 · Snapshapy 9/10 — 76 vs 11, $1.52 vs $0.52, 6.9×
The concrete problems:
- Meshy's first message ran about 6 minutes, produced no images, and the reply disappeared after a reload. Nothing on screen said it failed.
- Meshy asked for approval three times: 36, 30 and 10 credits.
- The print step added a choice card on top of the third approval card.
- Meshy's download dialog opened at 12.0 cm with Resize off, so the 3.2 cm height was mine to type.
For a 32 mm resin miniature, I would use Snapshapy.
Six minutes of "Creating image", then nothing
Meshy's first reply looked normal. It said it was "generating four distinct concept designs" and put up four "Creating image" lines.
Meshy's first try at message 1: four "Creating image" lines that ran for about 6 minutes.
I watched them for about 6 minutes, ≈385 s on my stopwatch. No image arrived. I reloaded the page. The Meshy reply was gone and only my message remained.
After a reload, Meshy's reply was gone; only my message remained.
- First try, message 1 — Meshy ≈385 s, 0 images, 0 credits · Snapshapy reply in about 9 s, 4 concepts
- Recovery actions — Meshy 1 reload + 1 re-send · Snapshapy 0
- Failures in the run — Meshy 1 · Snapshapy 0
The balance said 1,001 before and after, so the hang cost no credits. It cost time and a guess: nothing told me whether to wait longer, reload, or send again. I chose to send the same sentence again, and every Meshy number below comes from that second try.
The re-send: "Approve 4 selected" for 36 credits
The second try did not start drawing. It stopped at an approval card: "4 paid actions need your approval", Est. Total Cost 36. I clicked "Approve 4 selected", my first Approve click.
The retry: "4 paid actions need your approval", Est. Total Cost 36.
Meshy's retry concepts finished in ≈28 s, against 52.7 s for Snapshapy's slowest image. All four Meshy concepts were fully painted and each held an axe and a round shield: a runic defender, a berserker, an ironclad and a steampunk dwarf.
Meshy's four concepts: runic defender, berserker, ironclad, steampunk.
- Concept step, wall clock — Meshy ≈385 s first try + ≈28 s retry = ≈413 s · Snapshapy 52.7 s
- Clicks before an image appeared — Meshy reload + re-send + Approve = 3 · Snapshapy 0
- Balance — Meshy 1,001 → 965 · Snapshapy 1,057 → 1,049
Counted from my first send, Meshy's concepts took about 413 s.
Snapshapy's message 1: a reply in about 9 s, no card
Snapshapy answered the same sentence in about 9 s with a list of four directions and a line saying it would cost 8 credits. There was no approval card. The four images drew in parallel at 41.5, 41.4, 47.3 and 52.7 s.
Snapshapy's four single-figure concepts, full images: horned-helmet dwarf, grey scale-armoured dwarf, wolf-fur veteran, young brigandine warrior.
- Approval cards at message 1 — Meshy 1 · Snapshapy 0
- Concepts delivered — Meshy 4 single figures · Snapshapy 4 single figures, clearly different
Snapshapy's four were single figures and clearly distinct: a horned-helmet chainmail dwarf, a scale-armoured dwarf with a mohawk, a wolf-fur veteran and a young warrior in brigandine. Option 1, the horned helmet, went forward.
Message 2: the second Approve, ≈403 s against 331 s
"Use option 1 and make it a 3D model" got an Image to 3D approval card on Meshy: Meshy 7.1, Standard, texture 4096, Est. Cost 30. Approve click number two.
Meshy image-to-3D approval card: Meshy 7.1, texture 4096, Est. Cost 30.
Snapshapy replied "3 credits, 5–8 minutes" and started building with no card.
Snapshapy's reply to message 2: option 1 building, 3 credits, "5–8 minutes".
- 3D job time — Meshy ≈403 s · Snapshapy 331 s · 72 s longer on Meshy
- 3D model — Meshy 1 figure, 7,754,488 triangles, 262.4 MB GLB · Snapshapy 1 figure, 1,500,000 triangles, 106.6 MB GLB
- Approvals so far — Meshy 2 · Snapshapy 0
Two messages in, Meshy had asked me to approve twice and redo once, and its 3D step ran about 1.2× as long as Snapshapy's.
Message 3: resin advice, a choice card, Approve number three
"Prepare it for resin printing at 32 mm tall" is where Meshy's chat gave the most useful text of the run. Meshy's resin advice was specific: tilt 30°–45°, supports on the beard tips, axe edge and shield rim, and print it solid.
Meshy's resin advice and the "Repair Geometry for Resin" choice card.
Under the advice sat a choice card, "Repair Geometry for Resin". Selecting it and pressing Submit took two clicks. That opened a third approval card at Est. Cost 10, and a third Approve click.
Meshy's repair approval card, Est. Cost 10.
The repair ran ≈363 s and reported the mesh "fully watertight with 0 holes or non-manifold edges". My own check agreed.
- Clicks at message 3 — Meshy select + Submit + Approve = 3 · Snapshapy 0
- Print job — Meshy 10 credits, ≈363 s · Snapshapy 0 credits, 6.6 s · 55×
- Balance — Meshy 935 → 925 · Snapshapy 1,046 → 1,046
Snapshapy's answer: "exactly 32 mm tall with no slicer scaling"
Snapshapy's whole reply to message 3 was one paragraph: "The print prep is running (free, ~30 s): textures stripped, mesh reduced for print and sized so the STL/3MF comes out exactly 32 mm tall with no slicer scaling."
Snapshapy's reply to the print message: free, "exactly 32 mm tall with no slicer scaling".
The job took 6.6 s. The card read "60k triangles · from 1.5M · textures dropped · watertight".
Snapshapy's print card: "60k triangles · from 1.5M · textures dropped · watertight".
Snapshapy's reply also promised to report "the real triangle count and whether the mesh is watertight" afterwards, and no follow-up message came; the card itself read "watertight".
- Cards to answer — Meshy 1 choice + 1 approval · Snapshapy 0
The Meshy download dialog: 12.0 cm, Resize off
Meshy's repaired model was ready, so I opened its download dialog. It opened with Resize OFF and Height 12.0 cm. That is 120 mm, 3.75× the 32 mm I had typed one message earlier.
Meshy's download dialog: it still says 12.0 cm.
Four clicks got me the right file: switch Resize on, type 3.2 cm into Height, choose STL, press Download.
The same dialog after I typed 3.2 cm and picked STL.
Meshy converted its STL in ≈10 s, against Snapshapy's 40.1 s browser export. The result was correct: 32.24 × 22.20 × 32.00 mm, watertight, 1 body, 0 non-manifold edges. The point is who carried the 32 mm. My message said it, but Meshy's dialog did not; its own default was 12.0 cm.
- Default height in the export — Meshy 12.0 cm, Resize off · Snapshapy 32.00 mm, already set
- Clicks to a 32 mm STL — Meshy 4 · Snapshapy 2
Export → STL: two clicks on the Snapshapy card
On Snapshapy I clicked Export on the print card, then STL. The browser export took 40.1 s and the file was already 32 mm tall.
Snapshapy chat while exporting the STL from the card (40.1 s).
My mesh tool read it as watertight, 1 body, 0 non-manifold edges, 0 boundary edges, 27.75 × 19.57 × 32.00 mm, 2.47 cm³. No dialog, no height field, no unit to type.
- Print-ready check — Meshy watertight, 1 body, 32.00 mm tall · Snapshapy watertight, 1 body, 32.00 mm tall
- Volume — Meshy 4.58 cm³ · Snapshapy 2.47 cm³
Both files would go straight into a slicer. Only one needed me to set the size.
The tally: about 11 clicks and ≈1,189 s against 2 and ≈430
Here is every action beyond the three typed messages, in order.
Meshy STL wireframe: 7,754,470 faces, so dense it renders solid black.
- Meshy — 1 reload + 1 re-send + 3 Approve + select + Submit + 4 dialog clicks = 11
- Snapshapy — Export + STL = 2
- Meshy job time — ≈385 s (first try) + ≈28 + ≈403 + ≈363 + ≈10 = ≈1,189 s, about 19.8 minutes
- Snapshapy job time — 52.7 + 331 + 6.6 + 40.1 = ≈430 s, about 7.2 minutes
- Meshy without the failed first try — ≈804 s, 1.9× Snapshapy's ≈430 s
To be plain about it: Meshy's ≈1,189 s includes the ≈385 s first try that produced nothing. I kept it because I sat through it with no signal to stop waiting.
Meshy's print mesh is far denser, 7,754,470 faces with a 0.035 mm mean edge against Snapshapy's 59,928 faces at 0.309 mm, so Meshy's file keeps more of the fine chainmail and beard texture on a 32 mm figure. That density is what the extra time and clicks bought.
Two asides: 76 credits and a 387.7 MB STL
Credits are not this article's subject, but they track the approvals. Meshy went 1,001 → 965 → 935 → 925, 76 credits or $1.52 on Pro. Snapshapy went 1,057 → 1,049 → 1,046 → 1,046, with the header reading "11 spent", $0.52 at the Starter rate.
Meshy credits panel after the run: 925 left; Print repair −10, Image to 3D −30, 4 × Text to Image −9; Premium upsell beside it.
- Credits — Meshy 36 + 30 + 10 = 76 · Snapshapy 8 + 3 + 0 = 11 · 6.9×
- STL file — Meshy 387.7 MB (194.2 MB zip, ≈129.5 s on 12 Mbps) · Snapshapy 3.0 MB (≈2.0 s) · 129×
Beside the Meshy receipt sat "Get 3× more credits with Premium benefits". The file angle and the cost angle each have their own article in this series.
Final verdict: Meshy 3D Agent scores 58/100 for a 32 mm resin miniature
Judged as a run, Meshy 3D Agent was the harder road. The first message hung for about 6 minutes and erased its own reply without a word. The recovery took a reload and a re-send. After that came three approval cards at 36, 30 and 10 credits, a choice card with a select and a Submit, and a download dialog set to 12.0 cm with Resize off. That is about 11 actions beyond my three messages, against Snapshapy's 2, and ≈1,189 s of job time against ≈430 s, or ≈804 s if the dead first try is set aside.
Meshy earns its points on the concept art, the advice and the file itself, all conceded above. None of that undoes a hang with no error, or a 12.0 cm default on a request that said 32 mm in plain words.
Which one I would use for this job
For a 32 mm resin miniature, I would use Snapshapy. Three messages gave me a watertight, one-body STL at exactly 32.00 mm with 0 approvals and 2 clicks, for 11 credits. Plans are at snapshapy.com.
If you pick Meshy for the denser file, budget for three approvals per figure, and type 3.2 cm into the dialog yourself.